When publicists reach out to me to interview an author, they often send the book in advance. Last week, Dr. Kelly McGonigal’s Joy Is a Risk Worth Taking showed up in the mail. I pulled out the BRIGHT YELLOW book with JOY in giant letters and quickly put it down on my ottoman.
I don’t really want to read about joy right now, I thought.
Well, at least my inner ennui didn’t want to.
Sometimes we fall flat. Listless. Not in the depths of despair, more just:
I don’t want to. It doesn’t sound good.
Nothing really sounds good, in fact.
I adore Kelly and we’re simpatico in our work. But when you’re in ennui, or what psychologists call anhedonia, you’ve lost pleasure in the things you usually enjoy. It’s hard to muster up the energy to even want to be joyful.
So why do we emotionally flatline? And what can we do about it?
While procrastinating reading Kelly’s book, I made a list of all the reasons we feel the blahs. That felt much more satisfying than reading about joy. Then I made a list of what actually helped. And it became this week’s word of the week! ENNUI!
5 reasons we fall flat (and what to do about it)
1. Got what you wanted and still feeling blahh? Listen for joy
Tal Ben-Shahar calls this the arrival fallacy. We think we’ll feel joy when we get what we want: the house, the kids, the job, the amazing podcast guest. Then we get it, and something’s still missing.
Ten years ago, landing Stanford psychologist Kelly McGonigal as a guest would have been a milestone. I’ve made it. And here I am, interviewing her for a second time, and I don’t even want to open her book on joy! What is that about?
Arrivals leave us listless because we missed the joy of the process, and we lose perspective on where we’re standing now.
The way back is to tune into the present. What are the sounds that make you feel alive and content? The ones you’d bottle if you could? Birds chirping. Your neighbor playing ukulele. Kids kicking soccer balls across the street. Your cat purring. Collect them during your day and turn up your attentional volume.
How are you caught in the arrival fallacy? And what sounds of joy can you amplify that are here now?
2. Drifted from your values? In a sea of no’s, find a yes
Sometimes ennui is there whispering a truth in your ear. You’re off track with yourself, acting in ways you don’t like, and that feeling of being “off” is a signal to get your ducks back in a row. Looking at my own ennui, I had a whole lot to clean up: my relationship of over 25 years (more appreciations, fewer demands!), my finances (reign in the spending), and my health (please, please, please do some yoga).
You don’t have to fix it all at once. Look for a little opening. Find something, anything, that brings you back to your values, and say yes to it. Say yes when a friend asks you to go for a walk. Yes to eating at the table without your phone. Yes to planting narcissus bulbs.
What is your ennui telling you about your values? In a sea of no’s, find one values based yes and do it.
3. Have you been pushing hard things away? Don’t fake it
When you suppress bad feelings, you end up suppressing the good ones too. In a classic study by James Gross and Robert Levenson, people watched sad and funny films, and some were asked to hide what they felt. Hiding barely touched their sadness, but it dimmed their amusement.
If you’re thinking I don’t want to feel anything, you get your wish. Everything goes flat.
So don’t try to override your ennui with fake smiles and platitudes. As one of the therapists in my Therapist Sangha put it: let yourself dive into the rock bottom. Feel the ennui, but a little deeper.
Where are you dissatisfied? What are you pushing away that you need to feel? Dive deep under the ennui, and start feeling.
4. Overstimulated dopamine? Shock your biology
One of my favorite books (and interviews) is Dopamine Nation with Dr. Anna Lembke, chief addiction psychiatrist at Stanford. Her argument is that when we overstimulate our dopamine, our reward system adjusts and we feel less reward over time. Sugar, substances, and endless social media videos all do it. A nice cup of coffee falls flat if you’re used to a frappuccino with ten squirts of syrup and whipped cream on top.
The way out runs through a little discomfort. Cold mornings. Intense exercise. Wim Hof breathing. Do something that jolts you out of the flatness so you feel something.
This is called hormesis, a small dose of good stress, and it doesn’t just help your body. In a randomized trial from Elissa Epel’s lab at UCSF, women with high stress and depressive symptoms did three weeks of either Wim Hof breathing with cold showers or slow, relaxed breathing. Both groups felt better, but in the Wim Hof group, positive emotion kept climbing day after day. That fits Lembke’s pleasure-pain idea: sometimes you make yourself uncomfortable in order to feel better.
How are you overstimulating your dopamine? How can you shock your biology a bit more?
5. Got existential ennui? Find the we
And then there’s the first noble truth: life is dissatisfying. During transitions, times of great change, and the edges of breakthroughs, that dissatisfaction shows up more.
I’m midlife right now, listening to David Whyte’s Midlife and the Great Unknown. All the transitions add up to a grander feeling of ennui: my body, my kids growing up, my practice changing, heading into fall. Whyte calls these our periodic moltings. Like chickens when they molt, you get ugly, lose your fluffy feathers, and stop laying eggs.
Molting is natural. And, it’s something best done with others. Get out of your I self and into your we self. Cheer someone else on. Spend time with people who are in joy, because it’s contagious. In a 20-year study of nearly 5,000 people, having a happy friend who lived nearby raised your own chances of being happy by about 25%.
In a sea of no’s, find another person who is saying yes, even if it’s hard for you.
Joy as courage
So I eventually opened Kelly McGonigal's book, because I’m a good student. I read it, and I actually started doing it. As Kelly told me in our interview, “Joy is a values-based act of courage.”
Go read Joy Is a Risk Worth Taking, even if you don’t want to. Listen to this week’s Sangha on Ennui, and see what happens!
The practice
Listen for joy. Collect three sounds today that make life feel most lifey.
Find one yes. In a sea of no’s, say yes to one small thing that points back toward what matters.
Don’t fake it. Ask yourself: what am I pushing away that I need to feel?
Shock your biology. A cold shower, a hard walk, a few rounds of Wim Hof breathing. Something that makes you feel something.
Find the we in ennui. Spend time with someone who’s in joy, and let it rub off.